REVIEW: The Hall by Ro Bright and Pat Irwin – Fortyfive Downstairs


“I just wanna let them know that they didn’t break me” 

– Andie (Molly Ringwald), Pretty in Pink


When we meet grandma Tup, daughter Alison and grandchild Billie, they are almost at breaking point. Tup is suffering from FTD (frontotemporal dementia) and she’s combative, barely verbal and is only occasionally calmed down by wine gummies or a straw she thinks is a cigarette. Tokens of a past she doesn’t remember that trigger some deep-down understanding.

Tup’s house is a mess; years of hoarding for Alison and Billie to deal with. And there are stacks and stacks of Sacred Heart choir books dotted around. In the bathroom. Under the sofa. Reminders of a long-ago ritual of community connection and friendship. But in the years since she got ill, the local church circle have slowly abandoned Tup and Alison’s attempts to reunite the community chorists at the local hall amounts to almost nothing.

The Hall digs into the struggle of family-as-carers in the late-stage of someone’s life, where you must look after them, while already grieving what you and they have lost. The story is not so complicated, but it’s the details that get under our skin.

Billie, for example, is trans and is using they/them pronouns. Tup, because of the FTD, misgenders Billie multiple times, which leads to a panic attack. They understand the reality of the situation, but as a fifteen-year-old just finding a way to relate to themselves, it remains profoundly hurtful. Emmanuelle Mattana’s performance is energetic throughout – giving us both youthful joy and teenage pain.

Natasha Herbert's portrayal of Tup is complicated and layered. In moments of delusion, Tup is shedding clothes, but Herbert’s movements suggests a character trying to slough off her skin. The struggle in her head is made manifest in a body that squirms and lashes out.

Brooke Lee’s Alison is stuck in the middle, tending to her mother and child and trying to forge a path ahead. Sometimes though, what’s best for Billie cannot be reconciled with what is best for her mum. Lee’s portrayal of Alison is a compelling combination of warmth and freneticism.

Director Kitan Petkovski caps off an amazing year (The Inheritance, Things I Know to Be True, Sugar) by gently guiding this three-hander through the ins-and-outs of their struggles in the round at fortyfive downstairs. Actor-singers sit in the front row of the audience, on a couch, a pew, some metal chairs, playing other characters (a therapist, a priest, a flight attendant, etc), occasionally bursting into lush choral arrangements of original songs from Ro Bright and Pat Irwin.

The shape of show is quite clear early on – with the singers in the audience, we know Alison wants to connect with Tup again through mass song – but in execution, it becomes profoundly moving.

- Keith Gow, Theatre First

The Hall is playing at Fortyfive Downstairs until December 1

Photos: James Reiser



Comments